Major Players in VFX M&A

By

Joseph Bell

The VFX industry has been a busy place for M&A over the past 10 years. Netflix and Sony acquired established midsize VFX studios (Scanline, Animal Logic, Pixomondo). Private Equity backers financed roll-ups of small and mid-size VFX studios, one notable example being Fuse (now called the Pitch Black Group). Several VFX studios took on outside investment; a couple have even made efforts to go public. And Double Negative merged with Prime Focus World back in 2014 to become the world’s largest provider of VFX, animation and 3D conversion services.

A handful of major players in VFX stand out for their ongoing track records in M&A and robust deal pipelines: Technicolor, Cinesite and Framestore, the latter absorbing several VFX studios previously acquired by Deluxe.

Technicolor: The Strategic Investor

Group: Technicolor Creative Studios

VFX houses today: Moving Picture Company, The Mill, Mikros Animation

Merged: Mr. X, Mill Film, MPC Advertising

 

Technicolor and Deluxe were strategic investors looking to add VFX studios to their broader portfolio of post production services.  Both firms experienced considerable financial turbulence over the past ten years, with Deluxe filing for bankruptcy in 2019, and Technicolor’s Production Services group being spun off in 2022.  

Technicolor’s acquisition of The Moving Picture Company in 2004 had a huge impact on the visual effects industry, not least because MPC successfully offshored large amounts of their high-end Hollywood VFX work to a facility of thousands that Technicolor built in India.

Timeline

Thomson acquires Technicolor
Dec 2000
Thomson acquires The Moving Picture Company (MPC) for Technicolor
Dec 2004
Thomson SARL changes its name to Technicolor SA
Jan 2010
Technicolor SA acquires Laserpacific from Cinesite, rebrands LaserPacific locations as Technicolor
Jul 2011
Technicolor acquires Mr. X (Montreal, Toronto)
Jun 2014
Technicolor acquires Mikros Animation (Paris)
Apr 2015
Technicolor acquires The Mill (London, New York, Chicago, Los Angeles)
Sep 2015
Technicolor relaunches the Mill Film brand
Feb 2018
MPC rebrands back to The Moving Picture Company
Jul 2019
Mr. X, Mill Film and MPC’s episodic division merged under the Mr. X brand name
May 2020
MPC Film, MPC Episodic and Mr. X merged under the MPC brand name
Jan 2022
MPC Advertising and The Mill merged under The Mill brand name
Jan 2022
Technicolor Creative Services spun off as a public company
Sep 2022

Framestore: The VFX Powerhouse

Group: Framestore

VFX houses today: Framestore, Encore VFX, SDFX, Method Studios

Merged or shuttered: CIS Hollywood, Illoura, Centro Digital Pictures, The Computer Film Company (CFC)

 

Framestore’s acquisition of the Company Film Company in 1997 was perhaps the first merger of two modern VFX studios with their roots in the dawn of the digital age. 

Deluxe acquired CIS Visual Effects in 1998, later adding five other VFX studios to their group between 2010 and 2018. They then filed for bankruptcy in 2019. Framestore, which had been comparatively quiet on the M&A scene until then, acquired the former Deluxe creative services businesses – operating under the name C3M – in 2020. 

Framestore seems to favor absorption into their established VFX ecosystem to much greater degree than Technicolor and Cinesite, e.g. working to integrate VFX pipelines across their studios.

Timeline

Framestore founded
Dec 1985
Framestore acquires (and subsequently merges with) the Computer Film Company 
1997
Deluxe (founded 1915) acquires CIS Visual Effects
1998
Deluxe acquires Method from Ascent Media
Dec 2010
Deluxe acquires StereoD
May 2011
Deluxe merges Method and CIS Hollywood to form Method Studios
May 2011
Deluxe acquires Centro Digital Pictures (Hong Kong)
Feb 2012
Deluxe Australia acquires Omnilab Media's creative and media services businesses, including Iloura
August 2012
Centro Digital Pictures goes offline, officially closes in 2018
2015
Shanghai-based Cultural Investment Holdings Co acquires 75% stake in Framestore for £112.50 million
Nov 2016
Deluxe merges Illoura into Method Studios
Feb 2018
Deluxe acquires and merges Atomic Fiction into Method Studios
Jul 2018
Method, Encore VFX, Stereo D and other Deluxe creative services businesses begin operating independently of Deluxe as C3M
2019
Deluxe files for bankruptcy, receives court approval for restructuring
Oct 2019
Deluxe Entertainment Distribution acquired by Platinum Equity
Jul 2020
Framestore acquires C3M from Deluxe/Platinum Equity
Nov 2020
Method starts officially working under the Framestore banner
Jul 2022
Stereo D rebrands as SDFX
Sep 2022

Cinesite: The House of Brands

Group: Cinesite

VFX houses today: Image Engine, Nitrogen Studios, TRIXTER, L’Atelier Animation, Squeeze, Moov, FX3X

Merged or shuttered: LaserPacific/Cinesite Hollywood

 

Cinesite was sold off by parent Kodak in a 2012 management buyout. Three years later, the company embarked on one of the most sustained M&A programs in the visual effects industry, which has continued from 2015 to the present.

Cinesite bills itself as the destination of choice for SMEs in the VFX industry that want the advantages of being part of a group without giving up their brand equity – a “House of Brands” approach.  They have built a strategic competency in M&A, with a deal pipeline and knowledge of the marketplace that goes far beyond a single transaction.

Cinesite has grown rapidly as a result of their aggressive M&A program. While the level of symbiosis between their acquisitions is unlikely to be any higher than Technicolor’s, this is at least consistent with their overall strategy of preserving the different brands. Their portfolio companies have become less risky investments by being rolled up into a group, which will, in turn, have increased their valuation.

Timeline

Cinesite team formed as part of Kodak's Entertainment Imaging division
Late 1991
Cinesite headquarters move to London
May 1993
Kodak acquires public company LaserPacific for $30.5M and merges Cinesite Hollywood into it. Cinesite London remained independent
August 2003
LaserPacific sold to HIG Capital (and, subsequently to Technicolor SA in 2011, who rebranded LaserPacific locations as Technicolor)
April 2010
Eastman Kodak sells Cinesite to Endless LLP, an independent British investment firm, in a management buy-out
May 2012
Cinesite acquires Image Engine (Vancouver)
July 2015
Cinesite acquires Nitrogen Studios (Vancouver)
March 2017
Cinesite acquires TRIXTER (Munich, Berlin)
July 2018
Cinesite acquires L’Atelier Animation (Montreal)
Jul 2022
Cinesite acquires majority stake in Squeeze and their Mocap animation division Moov (Quebec City, Montreal)
Aug 2022
Cinesite acquires majority stake in FX3X (Balkans)
Aug 2022
Cinesite acquires majority stake in Assemblage (Mumbai)
Nov 2022
Cinesite receives $235M in new financing from long-standing bankers NatWest and Barclays
Dec 2022

Have these M&A programs been a success? Technicolor and Deluxe used M&A to tap into different sectors of the VFX market and expand their geographic reach. Their financial difficulties suggest that it proved difficult to realize substantial gains through cross-selling, economies of scale, and symbiosis between their portfolio of post production services. 

Framestore and Cinesite’s approaches to M&A are quite different from each other, favoring absorption and preservation respectively, but their strategies don’t rely on symbiosis between otherwise autonomous companies in their portfolio. They have turned out to be the winners when it came to maintaining stable, growing businesses over the past ten years.